Cheese Potatoes

This is a very dangerous thing. What I am about to present to you may change your life forever. Cheese potatoes, sounds innocent huh? Nope, one bite and you’re hooked. You will have to engage every ounce of self control not to devour the whole tray, seriously. The boyfriend had been talking about this dish for some time and I always just wrote it off as glorified potatoes au gratin. He chronicled its evolution from a mere side-dish to the acceptance that it really should be the main event. He explained that while it was delicious at dinner, it made an amazing breakfast as well, and seeing as his mom would make two trays there would be plenty of it to go around.

All I can say is that I am so happy this made it into my life. It’s about as good as food gets. This recipe comes to us today from Mama Evans.

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.31.14.png


  • 2.5 lbs russet potatoes
  • 8oz sharp cheddar cheese
  • 3-6 tbsp butter (we used 6, which I suggest doing, at least when you first try it. Go hard, or go home, right?)
  • 2 tbsp flour
  • 1 1/4 cup milk
  • 1 1/4 tsp salt
  • 1/4 tsp paprika
  • 1/4 tsp dry mustard


  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees & grease a 10-inch baking dish
  • Peel and thinly slice potatoes

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.48.22.png
AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.50.05.png

We used the mandolin you see in the background, oh and by we I mean the boyfriend because I’m still banned from operating it. I tried using that to my advantage when faced with the task of cleaning it but I’m told that I have permission to do that.

  • Grate the cheese

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.53.46.png

  • Cut the butter into small pieces. I found it’s helpful if the butter is cold when you do this

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.51.01.png

  • Now you want to lay down a layer of potatoes, sprinkle on some of the flour and dot them with butter. Then sprinkle some of the cheese on top, making sure to save enough for the top layer. We ended up having three layers, but depending upon the baking dish you might have more or less.

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.53.31.png

  • Repeat this process until you have come to the top layer. At this point you should have used all the flour, butter, potatoes and cheese.
  • Now in a saucepan heat the milk and the spices just until warm. Stir the milk concoction so that the spices are evenly distributed throughout the liquid

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.53.59.png

  • Pour milk mixture evenly, all over the potatoes

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 09.52.59.png

  • Bake covered for 1/2 hour and then uncover and bake for another hour

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 10.24.57.png

  • Now cut into squares and serve on pretty Crate & Barrel plates.

AcornWorkflow-2010.03.07 10.28.37.png

This was all that was left….OH THE HUMANITY

Many thanks to Mama Evans.

5 responses to “Cheese Potatoes

  1. This recipe looks absolutely delicious! I can’t wait to try them. Yum!!!

  2. Mimi it will change your life. I suggest having a few people there to eat it with you or its entirely possible to justify eating it all. 🙂 maybe we should get together after break and have a dinner party of sorts, make this and some other key items + wine=a good evening

  3. Yes, it’s true. The kids would eat this for breakfast the next a.m. Back in the day, it was something we would have once a week which led to our friends nicknaming us “the butterworths”! Ah, the good old days.

  4. I am so going to make these when I’m at home this coming weekend…1)justification not to eat them all 2) teach my mom how to make them so I don’t have to =P

    My mouth is watering just looking at the pictures! Keep up the good work!

    p.s. I love the hand modeling going on in this post ^_^

  5. I am still trying to shed the extra pounds amassed while eating this dish every week for years and loving it. Sadly it is only an occasional treat now.
    BTW, this dish goes great with a nice Belgian ale.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s